|
本帖最后由 良生 于 2015-4-28 19:59 編輯
6 l0 p) G9 ?2 `
2 M' \$ ^& N9 f: {http://nutsandbolts.quora.com/Survival-guide-for-mechanical-engineers-on-the-journey-to-create-astonishing-engineering
1 ?& F5 }7 F5 ]這是quora上一個(gè)工程師寫(xiě)的“機(jī)械工程師的生存指南:創(chuàng)造偉大工程之路”,,大家仔細(xì)看看,我覺(jué)得寫(xiě)得很好,。老外水平確實(shí)不錯(cuò),,完全符合8爺?shù)木�,,“基礎(chǔ)、基礎(chǔ),、還是基礎(chǔ)”,。看來(lái),,高手對(duì)技術(shù)的理解都是一樣的,。我撿重要的翻譯了一些,英語(yǔ)好的可以自己看看,,有錯(cuò)誤的請(qǐng)指正,。
2 u8 G+ B3 f9 a# i& @: B順便說(shuō)下,我為什么覺(jué)得寫(xiě)的好,,因?yàn)槠鋵?shí)在你做技術(shù)的過(guò)程中,,設(shè)計(jì)的過(guò)程中,真正復(fù)雜的,、難以解決的問(wèn)題,,歸根結(jié)底都是那些基礎(chǔ)的數(shù)學(xué)與力學(xué)知識(shí),這些系統(tǒng)的知識(shí),、深入的知識(shí)必須高強(qiáng)度學(xué)習(xí)才能掌握,。像“六軸機(jī)器人的傳動(dòng)結(jié)構(gòu)”、“多少個(gè)動(dòng)作的非標(biāo)裝配機(jī)”,,這些找機(jī)器多看看,,多拆拆,都會(huì)慢慢有辦法解決,。* A' D+ G w9 k& e, ?" i) S2 q
我唯一想補(bǔ)充的一點(diǎn),,就是還要掌握材料知識(shí),“材料”和“數(shù)學(xué)”,,是機(jī)械工程的精華,。
. O# g. X6 O- \2 }, P2 K7 l! o" H3 V" \* ? f
So I have written this like the advice Iwould give myself if I could travel back in time or what I really hope to seein the undergrads I want to hire. I hope you don't get discouraged/put off.
+ R8 d: r, Z, @我寫(xiě)的如下這些建議,希望你不要泄氣或厭惡,。如果讓我重過(guò)一次,,我會(huì)把它給我自己看。如果現(xiàn)在招人,,我會(huì)招這樣的學(xué)生,。
/ X0 |& b2 }$ U% X' b% ?First thing: Solidworks/ProE/AutoCAD/Rhino/Blender/CATIA and GD&T are notskills for degree'd engineers. You don't do a BS/ME for draftsmanship. It'slike putting MS Office on your resume. You can pick that skill up on your owntime.: F6 N' I+ G: V
第一,Solidworks/ProE/AutoCAD/Rhino/Blender/CATIAand GD&T這些不是拿到學(xué)位工程師的技能要求,,成為工程師不是一個(gè)畫(huà)圖員,,就像在簡(jiǎn)歷上說(shuō)你會(huì)MSoffice一樣,花點(diǎn)時(shí)間你能輕松學(xué)會(huì)它,。
4 p3 |* _* x; l" |' gSecond thing: I am talking about becoming an engineer here. You know, the kindthat build rockets and microengines (SandiaMEMS Home Page). I have nothing against grades, but I don'tcare very much for them. So I am not talking about getting the best grades., e2 ?8 ~$ H# v! i* n5 i2 a( u
第二,,我們?cè)谶@說(shuō)的是成為一個(gè)工程師,,是那種可以實(shí)實(shí)在在建造火箭和微型發(fā)動(dòng)機(jī)的。我不反對(duì)分?jǐn)?shù)制,,不是很在乎它,,因此這里我不討論如何得最高分。 Now. Here's what you need to acquireproficiency in through your 4-year BS.
9 H D6 m3 t6 R# ~; `+ k現(xiàn)在,,下面這些是你在大學(xué)四年中需要熟練掌握的,。
1 s: ^8 b0 w$ g" F% D0 b" |2 G0. Read Wikipedia.
# l% h" V4 w6 T! }( Z閱讀維基百科
4 v+ J b. q3 r7 g; @ G1. Programming - Start with Matlab/Python. Thengraduate to C++. An example of a programming goal would be to use this tocreate your own computational graphics engines. Why? Because this teaches youabout visualizing vectors, arrays, transforms and leads you tohigher-dimensional algebra. Make sure you can understand and implementRunge-Kutta family of algorithms before you think you are done. Arecommendation would be to ditch Windows and move to some flavour of Linux orMac. You need to understand concepts behind batch/shell scripting and importingopen source scripts to embed inside your own. If you don't do anything else inyour freshman or sophomore years, that's fine. But make sure you master this.) K) m3 M: C+ j! E2 y9 H: [/ e* R5 D9 J
編程:從Matlab/Python開(kāi)始,接著C++,。舉個(gè)例子,,要達(dá)到用這些語(yǔ)言可以自己編寫(xiě)一個(gè)圖像引擎。為什么,?因?yàn)檫@能讓你把矢量,、陣列、變換圖形化,,并通往高維代數(shù),。要確保你能理解和應(yīng)用Runge-Kutta的算法,這樣才算學(xué)好,。不要只是用windows,,也要領(lǐng)略一下Linux或Mac的風(fēng)采。要能理解batch/shell腳本語(yǔ)言的原理,,并能把利用重要的開(kāi)源腳本搭建自己的腳本,。如果你在一年級(jí)或二年級(jí)什么事也沒(méi)干,確保一定要精通這些,。
( L A, E$ ^; [6 a2. Linear algebra anddifferential equations - Now,most ME syllabi force the courses on you early on. But very few MEs trulyunderstand these topics. This is the source of all ME theory. I CANNOT STRESSTHIS ENOUGH! Most ME professors DO NOT understand linear algebra or itsimportance - they will fuck it up for you so you will be confused/avoidderivative topics forever. Don't take these courses offered inside yourdepartment - take them from CS or EE or Math professors. Or learn it fromGilbert Strang on Youtube. Tie this together with your programming to createnumerical simulations. Do NOT take these courses until you are done with yourprogramming. 線(xiàn)性代數(shù)和微分方程:現(xiàn)在大部分機(jī)械工程的大綱都要求盡早學(xué)這門(mén)課,,但很少有機(jī)械工程師能真正理解,它們是機(jī)械工程的根本,,再怎么強(qiáng)調(diào)都不過(guò)分。很多機(jī)械專(zhuān)業(yè)教授都不理解線(xiàn)性代數(shù)的重要性,,把它教砸,,去聽(tīng)計(jì)算機(jī)、數(shù)學(xué)專(zhuān)業(yè)老師開(kāi)的課,�,;蛉outube聽(tīng)GilbertStrang 的課。把它和編程結(jié)合,,進(jìn)行數(shù)值仿真,。不要等編程學(xué)完,再學(xué)它們,。
2 g" y+ m+ o! D' G, b/ `( [9 H' J7 N9 L( p
3. Statistics - Take this twice. Audit it as afreshman. Then take the course again as a senior. This will be the single mostimportant course you ever take as a professional in any field./ [4 }* q4 w1 ^* r J
統(tǒng)計(jì)學(xué):學(xué)兩遍,,第一年學(xué),,高年級(jí)再學(xué)。這是唯一一個(gè)任何專(zhuān)業(yè)都非常重要的一門(mén)課,。
# }9 ?' v7 R9 w# y- u( U4. Engineering mathematics -The rest of your life depends onthis. Pay attention to spatial transforms, Fourier analysis, Complex analysis,Potential theory, PDEs, Interpolation/curve fitting, optimization theory. Lookfor ways to implement these concepts using your programming skills. If you everwonder about the usefulness of any of this, or you get the choice to skip a fewtopics - you are doing it wrong. Good engineers use these concepts EVERYDAY.2 K. O- _( l/ K1 U
工程數(shù)學(xué):空間變換,、傅里葉分析、復(fù)變函數(shù),、位勢(shì)理論,、偏微分方程組、插值/曲線(xiàn)擬合,、優(yōu)化理論,。結(jié)合編程技能,實(shí)踐它們,。如果認(rèn)為有些沒(méi)用跳過(guò)去,,都是錯(cuò)誤的。好的工程師每天都用它們,。
@" x# g$ Z9 h$ _6 W- q) t5. Dynamics/Advanced dynamics - Take this in the Physics department.ME profs screw it up here again, they focus on the mechanics of algebraicmanipulation and don't explain concepts very well. Your objective would be tobe able to independently construct FBDs of complex interacting mechanisms, andgenerate classical non/autonomous, non/linear differential equations thatdescribe the time-history of the system. Develop a familiarity with indexnotation and tensors and operator spaces. Your indicial programming experiencewill really help you here.& Y+ d3 Q6 v/ Q) O$ E
動(dòng)力學(xué)/高等動(dòng)力學(xué):聽(tīng)物理系的力學(xué)課,,機(jī)械的教授總是用代數(shù)的方法對(duì)待力學(xué),對(duì)概念解釋不夠好,。你的目標(biāo)是能獨(dú)立建立復(fù)雜機(jī)械的FBDs(應(yīng)該指自由體受力圖),,能寫(xiě)出經(jīng)典的隨時(shí)間變化系統(tǒng)的自治/非自治、線(xiàn)性/非線(xiàn)性微分方程,,熟悉指標(biāo)記法,,張量和算子空間,你的編程經(jīng)驗(yàn)可以幫助你,。
+ U8 d) D5 y2 H0 _1 a6. Statics/Solid mechanics - Master Timoshenko Goodier/Theory ofelasticity. Even if it takes you the rest of your life. If you got throughpoint 2, you should be able to point out the inefficiency of the SFDs and BMDsand Mohr's circle concepts. Try visualizing the simple cases while cognizantthat life is not simple. Use your programming finesse to program numerical solutionsto your ODEs and equations.# F% k; W% q7 T/ N) I; d
靜力學(xué)/固體力學(xué):精通鐵木辛柯的彈性理論,,即使花去你的余生。如掌握了第2點(diǎn),,你應(yīng)該能知道SFDs和BMDs的無(wú)效和莫爾圓概念,。要嘗試把簡(jiǎn)單的例子圖形化,其實(shí)這并不簡(jiǎn)單,。使用你的編程技能去解ODEs方程(常微分方程)的數(shù)值解,。
2 `& Q7 e6 T7 {5 ?' s: w7. Vibration theory - If you actually got through point 2,you will find this a breeze. All they do here is study a second order,non/homogenous, non/autonomous non/dimensionalized ordinary differentialequation and the effects of parametric variations (mkc, forcing frequency). Ifyou got through 5, you should be able to figure out all the base excitation,seismic perturbation, isolation, rotating machinery concepts. If you gotthrough 6, then plates/beam vibration problems. If you got through 2 & 4,you will be able to work through MDOF systems and all the modal analysistechniques. This is where you segue to coupled SHO/QHO concepts.5 W; ~) X2 n" {. e# l; ~$ _, v5 P4 R
振動(dòng)理論:如果你熟練掌握了第2點(diǎn),這會(huì)比較輕松,。振動(dòng)理論主要是研究二階,、齊次/非齊次、自治/非自治,、變參/非變參常微分方程,。如你掌握了第5點(diǎn),你會(huì)知道怎么計(jì)算響應(yīng)、地震擾動(dòng),、減震,、旋轉(zhuǎn)機(jī)械等。掌握第6點(diǎn),,可以解決板,、梁的振動(dòng)問(wèn)題。同時(shí)掌握2和4,,應(yīng)能夠解多自由度系統(tǒng),,掌握模態(tài)分析方法。在這里還要學(xué)習(xí)耦合的SHO/QHO概念,。
* s' c' ?; B' a' h1 r' a+ `8. Thermodynamics/Fluidics - I am not the right person to adviseon these topics. But they are pretty straightforward at the undergraduate leveland mostly applications of differential equations and continuum mechanics.
/ w* t, u# A' l4 F+ X熱力學(xué)/流體力學(xué):我不適合對(duì)這部分內(nèi)容發(fā)表意見(jiàn),,但它們?cè)诒究齐A段并不難,并且主要是應(yīng)用微分方程和連續(xù)介質(zhì)力學(xué),。$ ^) u$ w7 S+ Q
If you followed instructions so far, everything else is a straightforwardapplication of what you should have learned by now. That's all you really needto be a degree'd mechanical engineer - math and physics. Everything else is aspecialization and extension of domains from the presented fields into specifictasks. This is also where you start encountering professional jargon. And don'tlet terms/eponyms scare you off.* q4 s5 a0 G9 u7 l
如果你按上面執(zhí)行了,,以后就是對(duì)你上面所學(xué)的簡(jiǎn)單應(yīng)用。這是一個(gè)機(jī)械工程師應(yīng)該真正掌握的,,數(shù)學(xué)和物理,。你以后碰到的一切專(zhuān)業(yè)問(wèn)題,,都是特定的任務(wù),,只是針對(duì)上面領(lǐng)域的應(yīng)用與擴(kuò)展,,以后你會(huì)開(kāi)始碰到一些的專(zhuān)業(yè)術(shù)語(yǔ),,不要被專(zhuān)有名詞和術(shù)語(yǔ)嚇到。
6 z, ~$ V* l) R' a1 H, I0 o7 QAlso mechanical engineers don’t generally design machines from scratch –hobbyists and mathematicians do. We follow standards for our industry, mix andmatch components, or use well defined algorithms to create a new one. There areconcepts in kinematic chains, algebraic linkage synthesis and design that areused here. So sure you can read about gears and machinery and 4-bar linkagesand cams and genevawheels, but it is highly improbable that you, as an ME, will create one. It ismore likely that a technician or a sheet metal worker will create somethingutterly brilliant. So if that’s what you want to do, figure on grad school. Youcan however use your solid mechanics skills to design the components towithstand pyrotechnic impacts.1 V+ t% |2 J) y. J7 P
愛(ài)好者和數(shù)學(xué)家也設(shè)計(jì)機(jī)器,,但機(jī)械工程師不從零開(kāi)始,。我們遵循工業(yè)標(biāo)準(zhǔn),,組合并匹配已有組件,,用已有的算法來(lái)創(chuàng)造新東西,,例如運(yùn)動(dòng)鏈、連桿綜合和設(shè)計(jì),。確保讀過(guò)齒輪,、機(jī)械學(xué)、4連桿機(jī)構(gòu),、凸輪,、間歇傳動(dòng)輪。有可能,,工程師創(chuàng)造這些機(jī)構(gòu)并不在行,一個(gè)技師或工人會(huì)做得更好,,但你能用固體力學(xué)知識(shí)去設(shè)計(jì)好零件,,承受極大的沖擊力。
- a7 E6 @/ |% p4 FI skip over manufacturing and 'product engineering' classes because they areshit, when taught in school. You can't master manufacturing sitting in a class,and you certainly are never going to learn enough in school about how to designa full product. Those axiomatic design principles and synectics and productlifecycle management and ideation and Gantt charts and brainstorming processesare bullshit. Nobody in real life does that. Those who do, are not engineers.If you really want to understand manufacturing, skim through ManufacturingProcesses for Design Professionals by Rob Thompson, then go talk with people onshop floors, or watch how it's made on Youtube. If you really want tounderstand the product design process, follow Kickstarter h/w startup stories. 忽略掉’制造’、‘產(chǎn)品工程’課程,,因?yàn)樵趯W(xué)校教這些,,毫無(wú)價(jià)值。你不可能在教室里精通制造,,你也不可能在學(xué)校學(xué)會(huì)設(shè)計(jì)一個(gè)好機(jī)器,。那些公理設(shè)計(jì)原理、產(chǎn)品生命周期管理,、甘特圖,、頭腦風(fēng)暴都是胡說(shuō)八道。沒(méi)人真的那樣做,,那樣做的人,,不是工程師。如果你想了解制造,,粗讀一下RobThompson的《面向設(shè)計(jì)的制造方法》,,去跟車(chē)間的人交談,去看youtube上的how it’s made,。想去了解產(chǎn)品設(shè)計(jì)過(guò)程,,去看Kickstarter。! F' [. S" s o0 U5 G' x9 L* _
Do not ever waste your time on survey or presentation courses. Avoid attendingschool seminars if you are not interested in the topic. You should attend allseminars that promise to show you math or process or cool videos. You want tokeep an ear out for examples and case studies that show explicit details of howsystems get modeled/implemented using math or experiments. Avoid 'design'seminars (usually a peddler from Wharton or Sloan or Kellog) - they are pretty,but pointless.& B! v g/ u* u" }8 H
不要浪費(fèi)時(shí)間在概述或介紹類(lèi)課程上,,不要參加不感興趣主題的討論課,。應(yīng)該參加承諾展示你數(shù)學(xué)、方法或酷視頻的討論課,。要時(shí)刻關(guān)注這樣的案例研究:清楚詳細(xì)的展示如何利用數(shù)學(xué)或?qū)嶒?yàn)對(duì)系統(tǒng)進(jìn)行建�,;�?qū)崿F(xiàn)。避免‘設(shè)計(jì)’研討(通常來(lái)自Wharton,、Sloan 或Kellog商學(xué)院),,這些看著美好,但毫無(wú)用處,。( D/ Q+ y9 L' ]" u5 c2 {/ x
Take all lab classes you can. ALL of them. All you can afford. Pottery too, ifyou have that option. Just drop in to watch other people work if you got thefree time. Pottery as well. Use the equipment there till you break it - You arepaying for it anyway. Make all the mistakes you can ever imagine there. ANDDON'T FUCK AROUND IN THE MACHINE SHOP BRO!!!
) ^$ f" W( |4 b參加所有實(shí)驗(yàn)課,,只要你負(fù)擔(dān)得起。在實(shí)習(xí)車(chē)間,,有空余時(shí)間去看別人如何工作,。使用哪里設(shè)備,直到弄壞,,你已經(jīng)為這買(mǎi)了單,。盡可能犯錯(cuò),但不要在車(chē)間那里打鬧,。( m$ x* m. }" w
Amongst other advice, find a PhD student about to graduate every year and getthem to mentor you. Don’t believe in that ‘I am busy’ crap – they all areusually on Quora or editing Wikipedia anyway. I speak from experience. Pickpeople from diverse fields – machine learning, operations optimization, publicpolicy, neurobiology, kernel development … You want to understand what they do,how they do it, what they use to do it and create a possible job network. Youdon’t want seniors to mentor you because, unless they go to grad school, theywill never be in any position to introduce you to great opportunities on timescales relevant to your interests.8 _1 A. E# ?. K
/ j5 S0 B0 F% t: R: P hNow, let's talk about being a professional mechanical engineer0 { X, |& }+ O: p
下面談?wù)勅绾纬蔀閷?zhuān)業(yè)的機(jī)械工程師) i$ t+ _1 y s% o& h
9. ReadISO/ASME/ASTM/ASTC/ASMI (standardsorganizations) standard practices. That's the only place where they really tellyou how theory meets practice. If you believe your university doesn't provideyou access to those - Sue them! Beg/borrow/steal. Whatever. But if you reallywant to know how things are done; Read the standards. Not the website and theirdiscussion forums. Read the standards." r2 m0 L) T: j7 k
讀ISO/ASME/ASTM/ASTC/ASMI 這些標(biāo)準(zhǔn)文件,,那才能告訴你理論如何滿(mǎn)足實(shí)踐,如果你的大學(xué)沒(méi)有,投訴他們,!跪求,、借、偷,,用任何方法,。想要知道事情如果做的,去讀標(biāo)準(zhǔn),,不是在網(wǎng)站或論壇,。
6 e0 M# S" Y) O& i5 { K# c5 Y1 b, i% ^; M9 @: M
后面還有,大家可以自己看吧,。/ ~* E1 q# e% f: Z; S( L
4 ^! t( d# O! g- |5 d8 U. r
7 G/ }) ]1 B5 k- n6 K; p |
|